We May Not Agree, But We Need Not Hate

“If you love only those who love you, why should you get credit for that? Even sinners love those who love them!” (Luke 6:27, NLT)

I truly enjoy blogging and exchanging ideas. There are quite a few things I choose not to engage in on this particular blog, though I might give it a swing on Facebook. One reason I may not engage fully is how we tend to get quite nasty in our disagreements. Sometimes we get into areas that really are difficult and navigating those waters gets downright choppy.

Two huge issues come to mind:

1. Rob Bell and the “new universalism” (which isn’t new, but we can call it that, I suppose).

2. The ordaining of homosexuals that was approved by the Presbyterian Church USA this week. (Or, any other issue dealing with homosexuality.)

There are quite simply matters that will not be resolved in this space we call “time.” Not our lifetimes. Not the next generation. We will just keep struggling along.

Yet, we get so disagreeable in our disagreements!

Quite frankly, we like our own positions and anyone who can’t see it our way is just plain nuts! 😉

In this vein, while I do not wish to wade into debates on particular issues, I offer a couple of thoughts:

1. I may not agree with you on your position. To be honest, I may even think you’re wrong. But know this: That takes nothing away from me respecting you.

For instance, I will disagree politically with President Obama 90 plus percent of the time on policy. That does not lessen my respect for him as president.

2. If I treat those who disagree with me in a way that seems to hold contempt, I am wrong. I may be right in my “position,” but that does not give me freedom to hold the other position with contempt.

For instance, I will disagree politically with Republicans AND Democrats on so many issues. Traditionally, I have voted Republican. I have since re-evaluated that position, but that doesn’t readily mean I would vote for a Democrat. That does not mean I need to say, “Anyone voting Democrat just can’t be a Christian,” or something to that effect. Nor do I accept someone saying, “If you vote Republican, how can you call yourself a Christian?”

In our current climate in American Christianity and American democracy, we have the position of  “We disagree, and we will be disagreeable doing it.”

I just simply don’t want to be that way. If I choose to act that way, or act in a way that would seem hateful to a position different than mine, how am I different? That is the question posed in Luke 6. Why just be nice to those who agree with you? The rest of the world does that! Big deal! Kingdom living calls for something different. It isn’t easy! But it just may make a difference if we, as believers, decide to give it a shot.

7 responses to “We May Not Agree, But We Need Not Hate”

  1. steve pearson Avatar
    steve pearson

    well said, Dan!

  2. Dan this is a subject very dear to my own heart and I am researching the whole issue of tolerance – interfaith or interspiritual for a future book perhaps. I think “respect” is the key. We do not have to agree – but for the future of this world we have to respect others’ views – mutual respect and understanding is essential otherwise we go down the slippery slope of fundamentalism and all that this entails.
    “No one comes to the Father except through Me.” That is our firm Christian belief. But are not others entitled to their own beliefs without us getting angry about it? Live and let live?
    I think some of the anger comes from feeling insecure about their own beliefs when challenged? I like to think this is behind the aggression of what I dub “The angry atheists.” After all Herod wanted to kill all the baby boys only because he felt his power was threatened by one Jesus Christ.
    best regards
    Eleanor

    1. I really like the thought of being secure in our own beliefs. Knowing Christ and his power allows me to look at other views and not be disturbed.

  3. this is a good post, Pastor. and the bible verse says it all. I like to keep using a phrase that a pastor says about stuff like this.. ‘we are to esteem greatness towards one another’ above all things. what ever page or bent they are on. I like the verse from James 1:19 “Wherefore, my beloved brethren, let every man be swift to hear, slow to speak, slow to wrath.” that’s in all avenues of living. there would be more loving people here in the church body and elsewhere.

  4. Very nicely stated, Daniel! Know too, that some of us can be more cavalier in our words than we intend to me, so keep up the dialog!

    1. The dialogue and the ongoing conversation is so vital. And with you, my dear friend, it is always welcome and so incredibly helpful to me!

Leave a reply to Eleanor stoneham Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.